Learnings
1. The usual barriers aren’t the problem
Signal, power, devices, cost and skills: the classic reasons people are left offline barely came up. Everyone we spoke to in Spain had a smartphone and found it affordable, and people had learned what they needed, whether that meant video-calling their kids or finding recipes on TikTok. Language was the exception. In Greece, half of the people we spoke to struggled to find information in Greek, from EU paperwork to vet instructions, while the information that really mattered was often hyper-local and only reachable through people.
“Most of the vet vaccination and medicine information and instructions were not in Greek.”
— Retired shepherd, Vlachokerasia, Greece
2. When the system fails, a neighbour steps in
Doctor’s appointments, school notices, social support and banking have almost all become digital-first or digital-only. When those systems fail, the in-person option has often disappeared, or it sends people back to the website. What keeps things working is the informal safety net of a village: you know the nurse, the mayor or the person at the counter, and they help you, unofficially. In a bigger town, that net would not be there. But informal, human support is not always available, and although there are IT support offices for citizens, they can offer very limited help with digital-first or digital-only services. Human, non-digital services and support options need to stay.
“If the page fails, I go to the office, but they can’t help me.”
— Music teacher, craftswoman and farmer, Sierra de Aracena, Spain
“There are no other alternatives.”
— Odd-jobs worker, Vlachokerasia, Greece
3. Using it isn’t choosing it
High use doesn’t mean preference. Many people feel they can’t opt out of digital technology and AI, because work, family, public services and community now depend on it. What they want is to understand their tools so they can make informed choices, to be able to repair and control them, and to choose what to use and what not to use, instead of being forced to use full suites of products when they only need one function.
“If I could opt out, I would. Right now I can’t, because people depend on me being connected.”
— Municipal sports coordinator, Los Marines, Spain
“I hear a lot and read a lot, but I have no basic knowledge. I don’t know how to start understanding more.”
— Rural postman, Sierra Norte de Huelva, Spain
4. Many ways of using it, one shared worry
People use technology in very different ways. One switches his phone on only when he expects a call, or to use the torch. Another dreams of browsing the internet with all his senses, like in a cyberpunk novel. Most sit somewhere in between. They value contact with family far away, access to knowledge and faster paperwork. Yet almost everyone shares concerns about its effect on children, on attention and memory, on how people relate to each other and the health of the personal and social fabric, and on the environment. Views on AI range from “a fabulous tool” to “absolute panic”, with fear and distrust the most common. In many cases, these negative experiences and this mistrust are becoming a barrier to using digital tools well.
“Playing games on my phone and seeing my mom in Australia.”
— Elderly support worker, Vlachokerasia, Greece
“Even the benefits are starting to be outweighed by my concerns. What good is it to have access to so much if I don’t remember it, and it makes me feel empty?”
— Care worker, Alájar, Spain
5. Knowledge lives between people
Local knowledge passes from person to person: in families, at gatherings, in the doing. Much of it is disappearing, and digital technology is only part of the reason. Young people leave, elders pass away, crafts stop paying, regulations change, and the seasons themselves are shifting. People feel this as a transition of its own, happening alongside digitalisation. As more things get sorted out by message instead of in person, the casual conversations where knowledge used to flow are also fading.
“In the hamlet, things now get sorted out by message instead of meeting in person, and that takes away something human.”
— Massage therapist and elderly carer, Alájar, Spain
“When I built my house, nobody helped me. My father made a stew and everyone helped.”
— Builder, livestock keeper and cork harvester, Los Marines, Spain
6. What people ask for
Asked what they would tell the people who build technology, they described tools that are useful but optional, with a person or paper always available as an alternative. They want tools that are not addictive, that protect children, that are honest about data and can be repaired. Above all, they want technology made for the common good, not for the profit of a few.
“Stop using us as raw material.”
— Massage therapist and elderly carer, Alájar, Spain
“Be kind, not greedy.”
— Writer and filmmaker, Arcadia, Greece